x

What Religious People Argue About

About Alcohol:

A: Okay so the lotion I use doesn't make me high but it does relieve pain and itchy feeling. So that's halal right?

B: Itโ€™s fine if used in a cream form. ย Itโ€™s medicine at that point and thereโ€™s no authentic Hadith Iโ€™ve ever seen that suggests alcohol itself is najis. ย Even fruit has alcohol in it. ย Itโ€™s drinking alcohol that is forbidden, and only then itโ€™s alcoholic beverages that can get you drunk (and you donโ€™t necessarily have to get drunk for it to be haram, if it intoxicates in large amounts then itโ€™s haram even in small amounts). ย Thereโ€™s more alcohol in a glass of apple juice than a non-alcoholic beer for instance but your stomach would explode before you drank enough to feel the effects thus it wouldnโ€™t be haram because it doesnโ€™t intoxicate in large amounts. ย This is the view Iโ€™ve seen most scholars take.

A: This is very helpful, jazak Allah

They think this a big concern - about the difference between prohibition of alcohol and other "feel good" things.

Left-click: follow link, Right-click: select node, Scroll: zoom
x